
Staying Very Much Alive Until We’re Inevitably Dead
Palliative care physician BJ Miller explores how beauty, pleasure, and connection help us feel alive until the very end.
November 17, 2026
When you put a drop of Japanese sumi ink on fibrous paper, it sits pitch black and globular on the surface, seemingly whole. Drop water into that tidy oval, and the form shatters. The ink plays, spreads out unpredictably, moves and thins. Now you have a planet, a cell, a storm, a Rorschach.
That’s what being alive is like: a shape that you think you control, but come to find out is dancing and unpredictable. Like sumi ink, made from soot and animal glue, our lives are made of our bodies, and our bodies are of this earth. Ain’t it a beautiful mess?
One of my life’s great joys has been practicing palliative care and walking alongside people while their bodies dance toward death.
When I say palliative, I don’t just mean the absence or diminishment of suffering. I mean palliative as enduring aliveness. Even when suffering is loud and angry and unshrinkable, there can be a second note. The young woman riddled with pancreatic cancer at the Nine Inch Nails concert. The little boy with spinal muscular atrophy floating in the ocean, weightless at last. The grandmother whose Parkinson’s is taking a toll, eating a giant piece of the German Chocolate cake her granddaughter just made for her.
Aesthetics are not the icing on the cake of aliveness. It is the flour: the basic structural element of our entire existence, the thing that holds our relationships together, the reason we usually choose to wake up when we might not otherwise.
Aesthetics: A Way of Knowing Through Feeling
And I know, I know, aesthetics feels like sort of an academic word. Today it’s often equated colloquially with attractiveness, but it’s really so much more than that. It was invented in the 18th century in Germany, where it first appeared in the dissertation of a philosophy student named Alexander Gottlieb Baumgarten. In Baumgarten’s vision, aesthetics provides a “perceptive” counterpoint to the rigid rationality of logic. The novelty of his proposal lay in the suggestion that philosophers concern themselves not solely with thought and reasoning, but give serious consideration to our capacity for feeling and perception as well. In some ways, I’m making a parallel argument with my life. In palliative care, our job is to not just manage the symptoms of our patients as they die, but attend to the feelings and perceptions that animate their lingering living. Baumgarten was interested in style, taste, beauty, art, and even the sublime.
Purveyors of the Sublime
When I worked for San Francisco’s Zen Hospice Project, chocolate chip cookies were as important a line item in the budget as were chux pads. We were helping people die, but integral to that mission was to help people live until that happened. We were doctors and nurses and social workers and cooks, but we were also purveyors of the sublime. We sang and laughed and entertained all kinds of punk rock requests. Smoking cigarettes. Giant canvases and oil paint. Parties with motorcycle gangs.
Aesthetics are not just sensory, but relational. So often the sublime is made possible because of community: the effervescent audience at the Nine Inch Nails show, the caretakers who made the trip to the ocean possible, the doting granddaughter. If aesthetics are the flour, community is the heat that turns it into something delectable. We do die alone, but everything until that last breath out, at least, is defined by connection.
And here’s one of the great secrets of death: those who come along with the person who is dying are often reborn. Caretaking for someone who is facing life-limiting illness transforms you. You are given the best possible education available in the power of the sensory and sensual in a finite life.
Where Words Fail
It has been my life’s path to tell the truth about this: that aesthetics are the have, not the nice to have. Words have failed me so often in clinical settings. Sometimes when I have shut up and just laid a hand on someone, or shared a piece of music, or laughed wholeheartedly, I have been far more graceful accompaniment. And when others have sensed my own fatigue with words, and laid hands on me, it has been a balm.
Perhaps this is part of why I have such a deep love for dogs. They seem to understand the power of non-verbal, unconditional love. The late poet Mary Oliver wrote, “A dog can never tell you what she knows from the smells of the world, but you know, watching her, that you know almost nothing.”
I still know almost nothing. But I do feel that I know this: we are alive up until the very last heartbeat, and maybe even the briefest of sacred moments after that, and we must minister to one another as if this is true. To be alive is to be at least nominally broken and out of control much of the time and in pursuit, still, of sovereignty and connection and intention and beauty and comfort and smells, oh the smells.
Do No Harm, Tell No Lies
The longer I practice palliative medicine in some form, the more I feel that doing no harm–at least the aspiration for it– includes colluding with no bullshit. Any patient who thinks they are in total control or, just as bad, have no control is harmed; a proportional relationship with control is the secret sauce of any good death. Likewise, any patient who has abandoned their own unique portals into aliveness is being harmed.
Up until the last breath, we deserve the exhilaration of our senses, even if they are dulled or beyond language or enigmatic to those who are on this side of the veil.
We must have a different kind of dance–the water dropping into the ink and the dog jumping into the river. Swimming while we can still swim. Floati



