Living Fully / Essay

Living Fully When the Future Has Changed

Oncologist and palliative care physician Arif Kamal explores how to hold onto hope and manage uncertainty after a serious diagnosis.

person hiking

November 17, 2026

Every year, millions of adults and their caregivers absorb the shock of an unexpected diagnosis of a chronic or serious illness. Ranging from high blood pressure to cancer, such diagnoses alter far more than the body. They often reshape a person’s relationship with the healthcare system, with their personal relationships, and with their sense of self.

As an oncologist and palliative care physician, I hear the hidden emotional toll that accompanies the visible physical changes, usually arriving as questions: What will this new, incurable diagnosis mean for my identity, my role, and my relationships? How can I maintain hope while balancing reality? How do I define myself as a person with an illness, and not be defined by the illness itself?

Such questions are common, and they speak to a core human urge to maintain control during times of change. To regain that control, people reach for predictability, guarantees, and certainty. Yet chronic and serious illnesses rarely cooperate.

Scholars have addressed uncertainty, philosophically and spiritually. I offer my patients three areas of clinical counsel.

The Certainty of Uncertainty

First, I share that uncertainty is certain. Real conversations among clinical teams, patients, and caregivers about accepting that reality are essential.

In conversations about a cancer diagnosis, I counsel patients daily that, despite the rapid expansion of treatment options, uncertainty has not diminished alongside it. With very few exceptions, oncologists cannot guarantee a therapy outcome, a predictable series of events, or the absence of complications.

A tumor may express a receptor at 99%. A therapy targeting that receptor may work in 75% of patients. But no oncologist can translate a trial of thousands into a promise for the one person sitting across from her today.

Both parties - the clinical team and the patient - want to chart a predictable course forward. But numbers cannot deliver what humans yearn for.

More Treatments, Fewer Guarantees

The growing obligation to discuss uncertainty is the price of scientific progress.

More than 300 new cancer drugs or disease indications have been FDA-approved in the last fifteen years. But that progress presents a different challenge: an abundance of treatments and a scarcity of certainty.

A study may tell us there is a high probability of a tumor shrinking. But oncologists cannot, despite our sincere wishes and a family’s desperate pleas, promise a specific experience or outcome. The conversation about uncertainty, more than the one about treatment selection, has become the most critical exchange a clinician and patient will have.

The second piece of the conversation I have with patients and families is about maintaining hope against the backdrop of uncertainty.

“If you can’t make guarantees, how are we supposed to have hope?”

Many associate hope with certainty, such that without a guaranteed outcome, hope feels unearned. Yet again and again in a person’s life, hope has been the primary emotion felt during times of uncertainty.

Think of a sixteen-year-old the night before a driving test, with optimism about passing sitting right alongside the worry of failing. She hoped anyway. Nobody had guaranteed her anything.

It is normal to hold hope, wish for a positive outcome, and wonder about possibilities, all without knowing how things will end. Uncertainty is part of the serious illness experience, but hope can ride alongside it the whole way.

Making a Plan for Worry

Finally, my patients and I build an action plan for managing the worry that uncertainty creates.

Such a plan often begins with naming the uncertainty and the emotions, behaviors, or outcomes that follow from it: “I can’t sleep the night before a scan.” From there, we look for patterns or predictable moments.

We normalize the experiences that are common. Many patients, for example, lose sleep before a scan that will reveal whether their medications are working. We then separate those experiences from the ones that cut deeper or disrupt daily life.

Managing those may involve mental health clinicians, professional navigators, or spiritual counselors. Clinicians should stay curious about what drives the harm caused by uncertainty and keep it an open subject with patients throughout the illness.

The Album on the Shelf

One image I return to in these planning conversations is a photo album on a bookshelf.

For some patients, time-bound explorations of uncertainty can validate emotions and experiences while reducing the risk of pervasive thoughts or spiraling. I ask them to imagine an album holding pictures of the uncertainty they carry.

Contained, and sometimes organized, the worry is limited to that one album. The album sits on the shelf in plain view. The patient can see it and knows it is there, but she rarely pulls it down. When she does, she usually looks through it with someone else. When she finishes, the album goes back on the shelf for another time.

That is the healthy position uncertainty should hold in the experience of serious illness: present but bounded, an occasion for conversations that help a person cope, and normalized unless it disrupts daily functioning.

The worry is still present, but it does not have to occupy every room.

Helping People Carry the Not Knowing

Despite the immense promise of new therapies and the still-unmeasured potential of artificial intelligence and other societal forces, we will never engineer uncertainty out.

That is precisely why strong, trusting, human relationships between healers and those facing illness matter so much. Living with a life-threatening illness is a deeply emotional experience. Naming uncertainty, exploring it, and then managing it becomes one of the most important conversations clinicians and patients will have.

Acknowledging uncertainty requires humility from the clinical team. It means holding optimism for the future and worry in the present at the same time.

Everyone facing serious illness deserves more and better days. While we cannot promise them, we can help people carry the not knowing. In the end, that is much of what healing looks like.

Three Ways to Live with Uncertainty

  1. Accept what cannot be promised. Speak honestly about the limits of prediction, even when treatment options are plentiful.
  2. Make room for hope. Hope does not require certainty. It can exist alongside fear, doubt, and an unknown outcome.
  3. Build a plan for the worry. Name the uncertainty, notice its patterns, and seek additional support when it begins to disrupt daily life.