Grief / Essay

The Time We Have

Grief therapist and author Claire Bidwell Smith reflects on her father’s illness and learning to live with uncertainty while staying present for the time they still had.

November 16, 2026

It’s 2002 and my father and I are in his Oldsmobile, driving a winding mountain road in San Bernardino County. His cancer has made him too weak to walk very far, so we have begun taking long drives together instead, wandering all over Southern California as he shows me places he thinks I should see.

My father lazes the wheel around each curve, telling a story about the time he ran into a college buddy while he was a soldier in a prison camp in Germany during WWII.

I’ve heard the story before but I’m eager to hear it again. Ever since my father’s cancer came back, I hang on every word he utters, always worried this might be the last time I get to hear one of his stories.

As he talks, I reach into my bag for my tape recorder. My fear of losing his stories has manifested in an obsessive effort to record him every chance I get. I’m hesitant to relinquish my tense grip on the arm rest, but I rummage for the recorder and hit the button as quickly as possible.

Get Back on the Horse

My mother died five years earlier. After her death, what began as a simmering worry about my father’s mortality has grown into a full, roiling boil.

I was fourteen when my parents both got cancer at the same time. My father’s prostate cancer went into remission quickly but after four years of chemo, radiation, and surgery, my mother died during my freshman semester of college.

In the years since, I’ve been working hard to find stability, with encouragement from my father who constantly advises me to “get back on the horse.” On the surface, I am doing exactly that. Underneath, I’m an anxious wreck.

The thought of losing my second parent before I turn thirty permeates my days. I cycle through endless scenarios about how his illness will unfold, how he will die, and what will become of me afterward.

In calmer moments I obsess over his medical appointments and research alternative treatments. In my more panicked moments, I beg him not to leave me.

“Kiddo,” he always says. “This is life. We can’t be here forever. We just have to be grateful for the time we have.”

But I don’t want gratitude. I want certainty.

I want someone to promise me that he will still be here next year. That the treatment will work. That I will not have to live in the world without either of my parents.

Of course, no one can promise any of that.

Negotiating with the Unnegotiable

This is one of the cruelest things about anticipatory grief: knowing that something may be coming does not mean we can prepare ourselves for it. Instead, we often begin living in the imagined future, rehearsing the death, researching every possible outcome, trying to negotiate with something that can’t be negotiated with.

And yet, my father’s illness was making me pay attention. Watching an old movie together in the middle of the day. Listening to a story I had heard a hundred times. Eating at a favorite restaurant where the waiter knew his name.

I marveled at these ordinary moments because I suddenly understood that they were not guaranteed.

The Girl with the Tape Recorder

I wish now that I had spent less time trying to manipulate the outcome and less time living inside the future I feared. But I also have compassion for the young woman who carried that tape recorder everywhere. She was trying to solve an impossible problem: how to keep someone she loved from disappearing.

Every so often I still come across one of those little microcassette tapes. What surprises me is how rarely I have listened to them.

At the time, I thought I was preserving my father. I didn’t yet understand how deeply his stories, his expressions, his voice, and his way of looking at the world were already becoming part of me.

The story he was telling me that day in the Oldsmobile was about being a young B-24 Liberator pilot who had been shot down and taken prisoner. For months he had no idea when, or if, he would go home.

He was twenty-four years old. The same age I was that day in the car.

I wonder if my father understood better than I did what was happening to me. Perhaps he noticed the tape recorder and understood exactly what I was trying to do. And perhaps that was why he was telling me this particular story. Eventually he told me he stopped trying to imagine what would happen next and surrendered to the life immediately in front of him.

And then, one day in the prison camp, he ran into an old college friend who was being held in the same barracks. My father took it as a sign that somehow, impossibly, he was exactly where he was supposed to be.

Perhaps our task is not to conquer uncertainty. Perhaps it is to learn how to live beside it. To let the future remain unknown without abandoning the life that is still happening now.

The time before the loss is not merely a waiting room for grief. It is still our life.